Monday, June 16, 2014

Mark Paul Richardson

The Memory of the World: The Library of Alexandria in History and Legend.
                The world was already a place of ancient civilizations, cultures and cities before there was an Alexandria for her famous library to be in.  Indeed, Alexandria the city was not much older than the library itself. [1]  Cities in the ancient world tended to be organic, to rise out of the landscape in an almost biological fashion.  Alexandria, born from the will of one man, was a rational expression of that will combined with the Greek intellectual tradition.  Periclean Athens was no more; it belonged to this same man, Alexander, and his Macedonian generals.  Alexandria was conceived and built as a city of marble, a city of broad boulevards, right angles, and monumental buildings.[2]  Alexandria’s famous library, itself a part of that reasoned urban landscape, was, in a sense, the ultimate symbol of that rational Greek vision.  The memory of the library would haunt the Western imagination down to our own day.[3]  In some ways, our limited knowledge of the great library has enhanced its prestige, allowing claims and assertions about it that do not lend themselves to verification.  What we do know, however, is impressive enough.
                Though Alexandria was to be a city founded on rationalism and planning, its foundation immediately took on a mythic quality.  This was, no doubt, due in part to whom the founder was.  Alexander was called “the Great” for a reason.  He stands like a colossus amid the pantheon of ancient personalities whose biographies have come down to us.  As a young man he was the student of Aristotle, who was himself the student of Plato.  Alexander’s love of the works of the blind bard, Homer, was well known to his contemporaries and to us from their reports.  We first hear of the site of what was to be Alexandria in Homer’s Odyssey, which Alexander would have known by heart.[4]
                                Now there’s an island out in the ocean’s heavy surge,
                                Well off the Egyptian coast – they call it Pharos –
                                Far as a deep-sea ship can go in one day’s sail
                                with whistling wind astern to drive her on.
                                There’s a snug harbor there, good landing beach
                                Where crews pull in, draw water up from the dark wells
                                Then push their vessels off for the passage out.[5]

                Alexandria is, indeed, in Egypt at the western most part of the delta region and on the Mediterranean coast.  The mention of “Pharos” in the above snippet from Homer is a reminder of Alexandria’s other claim to fame, its massive lighthouse.  This lighthouse was considered to be one of the seven wonders of the ancient world.  It is a reminder that though Alexandria is in Egypt, it is a port city, and it was founded as a gateway to the greater Greek and Hellenistic worlds.[6]  When Alexander arrived on this coast, in the winter of 332-331 BC, there was already a small Egyptian town on the site named Rakotis[7] that probably dates from around 1500 BC.[8]  For the world conqueror, this didn’t pose a problem.  As Arrian reports: “On reaching Canopus he sailed around Lake Mareotis and disembarked at the site of present-day Alexandria, the city named after him.  The site struck him as very beautiful for a new settlement, and he imagined that the city founded there would prosper.”[9]  Alexander was trying to integrate his conquered lands within a Greek framework, and Alexandria looked out to sea, and in some sense, toward Greece herself.  The city was in Egypt, though it would become very Greek.  Arrian continues by telling us that: “[a] sudden passion for the project seized him, and he himself marked out where the marketplace was to be built and decided how many temples were to be erected and to which gods they were to be dedicated – the Greek gods as well as the Egyptian Isis – and where the wall was to be built around the city.”[10]  There is a story, again reported in Arrian, about how Alexander wanted to leave an outline on the ground of where he wanted the city wall to be built.  Arrian states that he finds the report credible, which tells me that he knew others might not be so inclined.  It appears that “[i]t occurred to one of the builders to gather the barley meal the soldiers carried in their mess kits, and to lay it down along the ground where the king indicated.  In this way the city’s circuit wall was outlined.”[11]   Of course, barley meal on the ground becomes tempting to birds, but everything involving the world conqueror would later be seen to as a divine indication of favor.[12]  “The seers pondered this incident, particularly Aristandros of Telmessos, many of whose other predictions are said to have come true.  They then predicted that the city would be prosperous in every way, especially with respect to the fruits of the earth.”[13]  Alexander then left the site of his future namesake in order to continue his adventures.  He never saw the city, but as we shall see later, he was to return to it as a very revered and decorated corpse.
                Alexander left the development of Alexandria to his faithful viceroy, Cleomenes, who realized his king’s vision by building a city on the bay that was soon to become a cultural and economic power house.  The third century Greek poet, Herodas, wrote: “Alexandria is the house of Aphrodite, and everything is to be found there – wealth, playgrounds, a large army, a serene sky, public displays, philosophers, precious metals, fine young men, a good royal house, an academy of science, exquisite wines, and beautiful women.”[14]  It is the philosophers, academy of science, and good royal house that Herodas gushed about, that interest us here.  The royal house was that of  the of the Ptolemies, which would begin with Alexander’s general, Ptolemy Soter, and end with Cleopatra and her asp so tragically when  she and Marc Antony lost an empire to the Roman Octavian, known to history as Augustus.[15]  Ptolemy Soter had grown up in Macedonia with Alexander, where they had been childhood friends.[16]  He was also one of Alexander’s elite Bodyguards[17], a corps of the top seven officers in the army, and a general in the Asian campaign.  He is the primary source for Arrian’s account of Alexander’s campaigns.[18]  Soter “served as satrap in Egypt from 322 to 305 BC, and was king from 305 to 285.”[19]  Ptolemy was not only a brilliant general, he was a master politician.  After Alexander’s death, the generals who had served the soldier king split up his family and his empire with bloody coups, assassinations, and wars.  Ptolemy was wise in grabbing Egypt, a country that was the breadbasket of the Mediterranean world.  He was the first of these successors to Alexander to issue “brilliantly innovative coinage that stressed not only Alexander’s divinity but his own links with the king.”[20]  Then Soter did something to really connect his city with the divine Alexander; he stole his body.[21] 
                There are differing accounts of how, exactly, Soter came into possession of Alexander’s corpse.  One of the stories involves Peridiccas, a rival of Soter’s.  He was supposedly escorting the body from Babylon to Egypt as he planned to remove Soter there and take over himself.  Soter met him, took the body, and Perdiccas was skewered on the pikes of his own Macedonian soldiers as they were barricaded by Soter in Memphis.[22]  Another version has Alexander’s half- brother, Phillip Arrhidaeus, losing the body to Ptolemy in Syria.[23]  In yet another version, after the Memphis confrontation, Soter has the body buried in Memphis, but his son Phildelphus later brings it to Alexandria.[24]  In any case, Alexander became closely associated with the long-lived Ptolemy dynasty, and Alexander’s fame was unmatched in the ancient world.  His tomb became a place of pilgrimage, and added immensely to the prestige of Ptolemy’s city.  It is something of an irony that Alexandria, herself, would become the victim of a theft not unlike the one Ptolemy perpetrated on Alexander’s corpse.  The famous Apostle and writer of what most scholars agree is the oldest of the Synoptic Gospels,[25]Mark, became the bishop in Alexandria and his tomb was kept in the church that bore his name.  In 828, two men, Buono of Malamocco and Rustico of Torcello, both merchants of Venice, stole the body of the great evangelist and smuggled it home.[26]  This is known as the translatio of Mark[27] and is considered to be “the most prominent theft of a relic in all Christian history.”[28]  Because of this, Venice with its saint was seen as second only to Rome herself, who of course had the evangelist Peter.  Ptolemy’s reasoning was no different.  He had Alexander, and that gave his city prestige.  Still, Ptolemy was an ambitious man, and he wanted more.  He wanted his city to be the intellectual capital of the Greek world as well.  In order to do that, he would found a temple to the Muses, a Museum, and a library to serve it.  To do this he would rely on one of the most remarkable men in the history of the library, a man whose genius may indeed be responsible for the very existence of the library.  His name was Demetrius of Phalerum.
                Demetrius lived between c.350BC to c.283BC.[29]  He was the son, according to Diogenes Laertius, of Phanostratus, who was a native of Phalerum.[30]  Phalerum is a seaport on a small bay just south of Athens.[31]  He was a pupil of Theophrastus, who was himself a pupil and friend of Aristotle.[32]  This was to have a lasting impact on the Library of Alexandria, because as followers of Aristotle, Theophrastus, and Demetrius in turn, were to be of the Peripatetic school of philosophy in contrast to Plato’s Academic philosophy.[33]  Peripatetics took the whole of the world into their philosophy, and we will see that not only literature, but science and math were to be important at the library.[34]
                Demetrius rose to power in Athens through the strength of his intellect and his rhetorical skills.[35]  He governed Athens for a decade when it was ruled by King Cassander of Macedon.[36]   Diogenes reports that Demetrius was immensely popular in Athens, that many bronze statues depicting him on horseback or in a chariot were commissioned and set up around the city, and that “he rendered his country many splendid services.”[37]  When King Cassander fell, and Athens itself then fell to another Demetrius, this one Demetrius of Poliorcetes, Demetrius of Phalerum fled.[38]  He left his beloved city behind, but he managed to bring his reputation as a philosopher-statesman with him.  Eventually, he ended up in the city of Alexandria and joined Ptolemy Soter’s entourage.
                Demetrius was welcomed to Egypt and the Ptolemy court because he fit in with the cultural ambitions of Soter.  Demetrius was the right man at the right time.  Attica was in political decline and a pawn in Macedonian imperial politics.  Athens still exerted a tremendous amount of cultural power in the Hellenistic world, however.  Demetrius, with his intellectual credentials[39] and political experience, was now in a position to influence and serve one of the most powerful men of the day.  His attachment to Athens and its cultural institutions; his own experience as a student of Theophrastus; and his connections with other scholars who were more than willing to leave a chaotic city, all were to play a role in the establishment of the library.  Alexandria could become a new Athens, a new center of art and culture, a place of science and scholarship.  Demetrius had the access to the court, and the credentials in the intellectual world.  It appears, though we can never know the details in their entirety, that he seized his opportunity.
                It seems that “Ptolemy and Demetrius agreed on a two-point programme: (i) to establish a royal library; and (ii) to fund a circle of philosophers, scholars, and men of science who would form a permanent academy, to be known as the Museum (named after the Greek muses).  The Library would contain a copy of every work of importance to Greek scholarship.  The Museum would offer a place to anyone of exceptional status in the world of learning.”[40]  There were two models for this from Greek cultural history that were available to Soter and Demetrius.  One was from Plato and his Academy.  Plato focused on pure ideas, with little interest in other, “subsidiary,” areas of intellectual pursuit.  The other model comes from Aristotle and his Lyceum, where a whole gamut of subjects, from the sea to the skies, were seen as worthy of study.  Demetrius, as an intellectual heir of Aristotle, lobbied for the later model, and that is exactly the model that the Museum and its library were to follow.  “The Museum was, after all, a temple of all nine muses.”[41]
                Demetrius had less success with Ptolemy Soter outside the intellectual sphere.  He may well have been the tutor to the royal heirs,[42] as that would have been the traditional role for someone like him.  Aristotle himself had been tutor to Alexander.  In any event, Diogenes tells us that Demetrius got tangled up, on the wrong side as it happens, in the struggle over which heir was to replace Soter upon his death.[43]  When Philadelphus attained the throne, he “thought fit to detain Demetrius as a prisoner in the country until some decision should be taken concerning him.  There he lived in great dejection, and somehow, in his sleep, received the asp-bite on the hand which proved fatal.”[44]  There was no escape, as there had been from Athens, this time.  It does seem like this was an assassination or a suicide, but in either case, one can speculate as to what would have happened to this man if he had escaped once again.  Would he have started Pergamum’s library all that much earlier, or perhaps have established a school of philosophy in some other city?  In any event, his impact on the Library of Alexandria is undeniable.
                Before continuing on, it might be helpful to step back for a moment, and consider the role of books and libraries in the ancient world.  Libraries had existed for some time prior to that established in Alexandria.  Nearly four centuries earlier, Ashurbanipal’s library, a near match in size to Alexandria’s, had been established for the king’s use and specialized in materials that he would need.[45]  As a personal library, it would not have anywhere near the impact of the research type library in Alexandria.  Personal libraries had existed prior to the establishment of Alexandria’s library.  It would take the development of a book trade to lead to a more open, research library like that in Alexandria.  This book trade would be fueled by a demand for books, and this seems to have come to being in the middle of the fifth century.[46]  Aristotle was famous for the collection of books he amassed for the Lyceum, and he had a sizeable working library.[47]  This library was to serve as a model for the range of subject matter at the library in Alexandria.[48]  According to Strabo, Theophrastus inherited Aristotle’s library, which was then, in turn, inherited by the great man’s pupil and relative, Neleus of Scepsis.[49]  Some even say it ended up in Alexandria to form the core of the great library, but Strabo, “who seems to have known the library well, tells that Aristotle’s books had been buried in a hole in Athens, to keep them from being claimed by the Attalid kings, the rulers of Athens, who wanted them for their library at Pergamum.  Later the books – water-damaged, worm-eaten – were dug up and sold to the book collector Appelicon, who in trying to collate and amend the damaged scrolls introduced many inaccuracies.”[50]  Again, according to Strabo, this library, or what was left of it, was claimed by the Roman conqueror of Athens, Sulla, in his battles with King Mithridates VI in 88 BC and taken to Rome where it vanishes from history.[51]  It seems unlikely, in the view of this evidence, that Aristotle’s library was the physical seed from which Alexandria’s collection grew, but it most certainly was the inspiration, through Theophrastus and Demetrius, for the shape that collection would take.  “The library of Alexandria was comprehensive, embracing books of all sorts from everywhere, and it was public, open to anyone with fitting scholarly or literary qualifications.”[52]  By the end of the fourth century, the necessary building blocks for a great research library had been met: scriptoria had come into existence in order to feed a growing book trade; book dealers improved access to books; and, there was a growing body of collectors who built private libraries which, in turn, showed the value of libraries.[53] One of these collectors was described by Athenaeus in his book about life in ancient Greece.  Here is talking about a dinner party host named Larensis who:
Owned so many ancient Greek books, that he surpassed all who had been celebrated for their large libraries, including Polycrates of Samos, Peisistratus the tyrant of Athens, Eucleides, likewise and Athenian, Nicocrates of Cyprus, the kings of Pergamum, Euripides the poet, Aristotle the philosopher, Theophrastus and Nelius, who preserved the books of the last two named.  From Nelius, he says our King Ptolemy surnamed Philadelphus, purchased them all and transferred them with those which he procured in Athens and at Rhodes to his beautiful capitol, Alexandria.[54]

 These trends, when they reached a critical mass, encouraged Ptolemy Soter and Demetrius of Phalerum to establish the great library.[55]
                Now that we have some idea of what types of collections were destined for the library, let’s take a look at the physical library itself.  It is here, regretfully, that our information is so poor.  The situation is so hopeless, that John Willis Clark in his famous study of the physical nature of libraries[56]dismisses any hope of exploring those aspects of the more famous library at Alexandria and quickly turns his attention to Pergamum, where there are remains of that library that can be explored.  In addition, Luciano Canfora, who wrote a celebrated book that was half fictional (intentionally) on the library at Alexandria, reiterates this point by noting that: “The celebrated archaeologist Christian Callmer, for example, whose work on the libraries of antiquity is of unrivalled completeness, remarks cautiously that we actually know nothing of the ‘architectural plan’ of the library at Alexandria; and he adds a note pointing out that the only surviving description is Strabo’s.”[57]   Nicholas Basbanes, in his history and travelogue about books and libraries, writes that: “Unlike Athens and Rome, where architectural ruins endure in glorious profusion, modern-day Alexandria offers little visible evidence of its noble heritage, and the original city exists only as a glittering memory.  Whatever graceful edifice was not pillaged over the centuries was toppled by earthquakes or leveled in modern times by indifferent developers.”[58]
                The library appears to have been, in fact, two libraries; or better yet, a main library and a secondary library that may have been made necessary by a need for additional space or to have served a different clientele.  “Such evidence as there is suggest that it was in the ‘palace quarter’ of Alexandria, perhaps adjacent to the Museum, and was supplemented by a subsidiary building near the Serapeum.”[59]  The scholar Edward Alexander Parsons describes the library like this: “A covered colonnade connected the Museum with an adjacent stately building, also in white marble and stone, architecturally harmonious, indeed forming an integral part of the vast pile, dedicated to learning by the first Ptolemy in following the advice and genius of Demetrius of Phalerum.  This is the famous Library of Alexandria, the ‘mother’ library of the Museum, the Alexandriana, truly the foremost wonder of the ancient world.”[60]  He then goes on to add that it was made up of “…ten great halls, whose ample walls were lined with spacious armaria, numbered and titled, were housed the myriad manuscripts containing the wisdom, knowledge, and information, accumulated by the genius of the Hellenic peoples.”[61] 
                Whatever the library looked like physically, its manner of building its collections became the stuff of legend.  The pockets of the Ptolemy dynasty were deep indeed, and they scoured the ancient world for texts to feed their library.  “By royal decree, all ships stopping at Alexandria had to surrender any books they were carrying; these books were copied, and the originals (sometimes the copies) were returned to their owners while the duplicates (sometimes the originals) were kept in the library.”[62]  The master texts of the great tragedies of Greek literature were kept in Athens.  The Ptolemies paid a huge deposit to obtain them for copying, and then forfeited that deposit in order to keep the originals.[63]  Soon Alexandria found itself in competition with Pergamum for both books and scholars.  The passion for acquiring works led to a sort of illicit trade in spurious works and to attempts to make contemporary works appear antique.[64]  It also led to imperfect transcriptions in the desire for speedy production.[65]
                Now we have learned what we can of Alexandria, its library, and its method of procuring the volumes that fit into its philosophy of library building.  It’s time to meet the librarians and scholars who cemented its reputation.
                The primary source for the initial organization and the identities of the earliest librarians comes from the account of the Byzantine scholar and commentator, John Tzetzes,[66] who lived in the 12th century.[67]   It is important to understand how we know what we do about the ancient world, even though so many primary sources have been lost down through the ages.  In the case of Tzetzes, it is because of the uses of the tools of the scholar that were first established at the library in Alexandria.  These tools are: “glosses, scholia, and short or longer (broken or continuous) commentaries.”[68]  It is from the scholium that we derive our information from Tzetzes.  A scholium is “usually a short marginal note, explaining a difficult passage, or criticizing or interpreting the text or the author’s treatment of his theme; or again it may be a comment quite remote from the adjacent text which the scholiast in some way thinks is germane.”[69]  Tzetzes was writing a Prolegomena to his Commentary on Aristophanes.[70]  It is here that he describes the library in Alexandria and the early librarians.  “Tzetzes evidently reaches back ultimately to some Alexandrian sources for the Ptolemaic period, but his immediate authorities were much later material, such as grammarian’s editions and prolegomena to Aristophanes, and the scholia to Dionysius of Thrace.”[71]
                The next important source for the early library and librarians is contained in the ‘Suda’, which contained biographies of poets and scholars.[72]  The Suda basically translates as ‘the Fortress.’[73]  It is a Greek literary encyclopedia and lexicon from around the first millennia AD that has articles on Greek history and literature.[74]  The compiler relied on many sources now lost to us; so, he is now a primary source himself.  Many of those sources would have originated with the generations of scholars at Alexandria.
                The third major source for understanding who the early librarians were come from a fragment of papyrus known as the “Oxyrhynchus papyrus[75] of the second century AD, containing a historical and mythological chrestomathy; the second column of this gives a list of the Alexandrian Librarians, with some undoubted errors and not a few obscurities.”[76]  It is well accepted, using the available sources, that Zenodotus was the first chief librarian, but after him there is some scholarly disagreement, which depends on which sources the scholars in question accept as most reliable.  As none of the sources are entirely conclusive, I will do my best to not get mired down in the minutia.[77]
                Zenodotus of Ephesus became the first head[78] of the Alexandrian Library (c.285 – c.270BC) and is credited with dividing Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey into 24 books each.[79]  He may have produced editions of each and he certainly worked on the texts of the various editions that showed up in Alexandria from all over the Mediterranean world.  Traces of his critical work still survive in the Homeric scholia, and he is credited with the invention of the obelos, a critical sign to mark doubtful passages of text.[80]  Providing standard texts of the great writers of antiquity would be one of the hallmarks of the scholars of the library.  Zenodotus also made an alphabetical list of rare words, a glossary, which would eventually inspire that other great member of the library, Callimachus, in assembling his own list.[81]  Zenodotus was not the first to make a list of such words; he was, in fact, following in the footsteps of the immensely popular Philitas, a scholar and poet who lived around 300 BC.[82]  Philitas put together a work called Miscellaneous Words which was a compendium of archaic words from literature.[83]  The work of Philitas was lacking organizational integrity, however.
                Callimachus, who shows up on several versions of the available lists of librarians at the Alexandrian Library, was probably never a chief librarian.  He was, however, a classic example of his age: a poet and a scholar.[84]  As a poet, he was influential.[85]  We still have some of his work, though much has been lost.[86]  As a librarian, his claim to fame is as a cataloger.[87]  He was born between 310 and 305 BC in Cyrene, North Africa.[88]  He died somewhere around 240 BC.[89]  It was Ptolemy II, Philadelphus, son and successor to Soter, who directed Callimachus to prepare a catalog of the library’s holdings.[90]  This was no easy task.  The library’s holdings were already vast and growing all the time.  The first thing that had to be decided on was a scheme of organization.  “Callimachus divided the library into shelves or tables (pinakoi) arranged in eight classes or subjects: drama, oratory, lyric poetry, legislation, medicine, history, philosophy and miscellany.”[91]  Known as the Pinakes, the full title of this catalog was Tables of Those Who Were Outstanding in Every Phase of Culture, and Their Writings.[92]  This catalog reputedly came to one hundred and twenty books, or scrolls.[93]  This would be equal to about twelve average-sized books today.[94]  He had the advantage of having all the works deemed important in Greek literature in one location, and his labor produced a shelf-list that was a critical reference tool for future scholars.[95]  “With Callimachus, the library became an organized reading-space.”[96]  Books were now organized under subject headings and alphabetically.[97]  Callimachus would not finish his great work.  It was too vast an enterprise and with the constant influx of books, a never ending one.  But he did set down the master plan, and libraries, with obvious improvements, have followed his lead to this day.
                The scholars and critics at the library eventually established which works were the most important from the Greek literary heritage.  They also set out to establish the texts of those works and to provide commentaries for readers.  In epic poetry Homer and Hesiod headed the pantheon.[98]  Lyric poets included: Pindar, Bacchylides, Sappho, Anacieon, Stesichorus, Ibycus, Alcman, and Alcaeus.[99]  For the stage, Aeschylus, Sophocles, Euripides, Aristophanes, Eupolis and Cratinus were designated.[100]  There were also philosophers and historians and even orators.  These same names still dominate the ancient Greek canon.  And not everything in the library was Greek, or even, later, Latin.  Tradition discusses the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible, as being composed at the library and the library “almost certainly had a copy of the chronological list of the pharaohs that an Egyptian priest named Manetho translated from Egyptian into Greek.”[101]
                From the beginning, the library and its librarians made their mark on literary culture.  The next great librarian, Eratosthenes (Director from 245-205 BC) brought science to the forefront.  He was so knowledgeable, in so many fields, that envious colleagues dubbed him “number two”; in other words, he was second best at everything.[102]   This was not true in regard to geography, at least.[103]  The scholars at the library, who were well taken care of, were to spawn the expected amount of jealousy.[104]  Erastothenes was, in fact, the first person to measure the size of the earth with some accuracy.  He was not the first person to realize that the earth was a globe.  Both Pythagoras and Aristotle knew as much in the fourth century BC.[105]  Erastothenes developed an ingenious method of measurement that relied on the summer solstice, a fair knowledge of the distance between Alexandria and Syene, Egypt, and the measurement of shadows at a particular time of day.  His final measurement was within 4 percent of the modern figure.[106]  He was also to influence Ptolemy, the Greek astronomer, mathematician, and geographer who was to dominate the view of the earth held by the learned for nearly 1300 years.[107]  He was born in Upper Egypt and lived in worked in Alexandria from AD 146 to c. 170.[108]  Besides having the great library at his disposal, which held the works of Erastothenes, he was able to supplement this knowledge and verify it by his “personal contact with ship-masters, merchant travelers and other visitors to Alexandria, the hub of trade between east and west.”[109]
                The next great librarian, depending on which list you believe, was the grammarian Aristophanes of Byzantium.  It is around him that the legend of the rivalry between Eumenes II of Pergamon (197 – 159 BC) and the Ptolemies of Alexandria finds its most famous illustration.[110]  Aristophanes was supposedly imprisoned to keep him from leaving Alexandria for the promise of a new job at Pergamon.[111]  One wonders how many librarians in history have risked incarceration for the chance at a new job.
                With Aristophanes of Byzantium, a shift back from science to literature was made.  Literature would maintain it sway at the library but the other disciplines would continue to be pursued, as we have seen with Ptolemy the Geographer.
                So now it remains to explore just how the library disappeared as a working entity from history, for it never has disappeared from the history of the imagination.
                Not inappropriately, we have our choice of destructions with Alexandria’s famous library.[112]  Not unlike mythical Atlantis, the destruction is almost seen as being as critical to the story as the life that made it famous.  That prominent chronicler of the fall of Rome, Edward Gibbon, knew he was expected to deal with the fall of the library in his great work, but showed that he found the task somewhat distasteful.[113]  “I should deceive the expectation of the reader if I passed in silence the fate of the Alexandrian Library, as it is described by the learned Abulpharagius.”[114]  He goes on to repeat the story of the Arabian chief, Amrou, who conquered the city and, at the direction of his Caliph, Omar, who was requested to give direction as to the fate of the library, is supposed to have said: “If these writings of the Greeks agree with the book of God, they are useless and need not be preserved: if they disagree, they are pernicious and ought to be destroyed.”[115]  The volumes were thus duly delivered to the four thousand baths of the city as fuel to heat the water.[116]  It supposedly took half a year to consume the fuel, it was so plentiful.[117]    Gibbon, no mean judge of history and the character of its principal actors, denies that this story is accurate.  He does note that countless Christian chroniclers have quoted it with righteous dismay, but the Christian chroniclers in the city at the time, or there shortly thereafter, fail to mention such an act.[118]  So, if the Arabs didn’t burn the library, what happened to it?
                Another story claims that it was burned by Julius Caesar himself.  Gibbon mentions this story, as well as bringing up the fact that zealous Christians were as likely to destroy the Pagan library as anyone.[119]  As far as the story of Julius Caesar goes, it seems he was trapped by his enemies in the city.  They cut off his supply of water by diverting the canals, and they attempted to cut off his escape by sea; and this led to his setting his own ships on fire, and they, in turn, set the waterfront of the city to blaze.[120]  The library was lost.  Later commentators do not doubt that perhaps the waterfront storage of books intended for the library may have been lost in this incident, but they doubt the entire library was destroyed.[121]  In fact, we don’t know what happened to the library.  It may simply have withered away, uncared for, by a new Christian, and then later, Muslim, city that did not value it.[122]
                In conclusion, the library, or libraries, of Alexandria functioned very similarly to a modern research library, or better yet, like a modern think-tank attached to a research library.  The goal was research; the fellows were invited, and only the best were considered.  A modern library has recently been constructed in Alexandria.  Much has been made of the inspiration provided by the lost library.  Yet this 21st century library is very different than its ancient forebear.  Unlike the old library, it is truly public.  There is no real pretense to collecting all of human knowledge, and Alexandria herself is no longer a cultural or intellectual force in the world.  There are plenty of computers in the new library, but most telling, the greatest minds of the age will not flock to this modern marvel like they flocked to the splendid court of Ptolemy Soter and his offspring.  We live in different times, but the ancient library managed a profound contribution before it drifted from reality to imagination: it survives in the memory of the world.









Bibliography

Ackroyd, Peter. Venice: Pure City. New York: Nan A. Talese/Doubleday, 2009.
Avery, Catherine B., ed. The New Century Classical Handbook. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, Inc., 1962.
Basbanes, Nicholas A. Patience and Fortitude: A Roving Chronicle of Book People, Book Places, and Book Culture. New York: HarperCollins Publishers Inc., 2001.
Battles, Matthew. Library: An Unquiet History. New York: W. W. Norton, 2003.
Baynham, Elizabeth. "Arrian's Sources and Reliability." The Landmark Arrian: The Campaigns of Alexander, Anabasis Alexandrou. Ed. James Romm. Trans. Pamela Mensch. New York: Pantheon Books, 2010. 325-332.
Bergreen, Laurence. Marco Polo: From Venice to Xanadu. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2007.
Brazil, Wendy. "Alexandria: The Umbilicus of the Ancient World." The Library of Alexandria: Centre of Learning in the Ancient World. Ed. Roy MacLeod. New York: I. B. Tauris, 2000, 2001, 2002. 35-59.
Canfora, Luciano. The Vanished Library: A Wonder of the Ancient World. Trans. Martin Ryle. Berkely: The University of California Press, 1990.
Casson, Lionel. Libraries of the Ancient World. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2001.
Clark, John Willis. The Care of Books: An Essay on the Development of Libraries and their Fittings, from the earliest times to the end of the Eighteenth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1901.
Diogenes Laertius. Lives of the Eminent Philosophers. Trans. R. D. Hicks. Vol. I. London: William Heinemann, 1925.
—. Lives of the Eminent Philosophers. Trans. R. D. Hicks. Vol. II. London: William Heinemann, 1925.
Durrell, Lawrence. Justine. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1957.
Eliot, T. S. "The Wasteland." The New Oxford Book of American Verse. Ed. Richard Ellmann. New York: Oxford University Press, 1976. 604.
Eusebius. The Ecclesiastical History. Trans. Kirsopp Lake. Vol. I. London: William Heinemann, 1926.
—. The Ecclesiastical History. Trans. J. E. L. Oulton. Vol. II. London: William Heinemann, 1932.
Forster, E. M. Alexandria: A History and a Guide. Woodstock: The Overlook Press, 1974.
Fraser, P. M. Ptolemaic Alexandria: I Text . Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1972.
Gibbon, Edward. The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire: Mohammed and the Rise of the Arabs. Ed. Felipe Fernandez Armesto. Vol. VI. London: The Folio Society, 1988.
Heller-Roazen, Daniel. "Tradition's Destruction: On the Library of Alexandria." October 100 Spring (2002): 133-153.
Homer. The Odyssey. Trans. Robert Fagles. New York: Penguin Books, 1996.
Howard, Deborah. "Alexandria." The Classical Tradition. Ed. Anthony Grafton, Glenn W. Most and Salvatore Settis. Cambridge, Massachusetts and London, England: The Belknap Press of Harvard University, 2010. 31-32.
Howatson, M. C., ed. The Oxford Companion to Classical Literature. 3rd. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.
Howse, Derek and Michael Sanderson. The Sea Chart: An Historical Survey based on the Collections in the National Maritime Museum. New York: McGraw - Hill Book Company, 1973.
Knowles, Elizabeth, ed. Oxford Dictionary of Quotations. 7th. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009.
Knox, Bernard, ed. The Norton Book of Classical Literature. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1993.
—. The Oldest Dead White European Males and Other Reflections on the Classics. New York and London: W. W. Norton & Company, 1993.
Lloyd, Alan B. "The Ptolemaic Period (332-30 BC)." The Oxford History of Ancient Egypt. Ed. Ian Shaw. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000. 395-421.
MacLeod, Roy, ed. The Library of Alexandria: Centre of Learning in the Ancient World. New York: I. B. Tauris, 2000, 2001, 2002.
Manguel, Alberto. A History of Reading. New York: Viking, 1996.
McEvedy, Colin. Cities of the Classical World: An Atlas and Gazetteer of 120 Centres of Ancient Civilization. Ed. Douglas Stuart Oles. London: Allen Lane, 2011.
Nelles, Paul. "Libraries." The Classical Tradition. Ed. Anthony Grafton, Glenn W. Most and Salvatore Settis. Cambridge, Massachusetts, and London, England: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2010. 532-536.
Parsons, Edward Alexander. The Alexandrian Library: Glory of the Hellenistic World; Its Rise, Antiquities, and Destructions. Amsterdam - London - New York: The Elsevier Press, 1952.
Peacock, David. "The Roman Period (30 BC - AD 311)." The Oxford History of Ancient Egypt. Ed. Ian Shaw. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000. 422-455.
Plutarch. Lives: Volume II; The Age of Empire-Builders. Ed. Arthur Hugh Clough. Trans. John Dryden. London: The Folio Society, 2010.
—. Lives: Volume IV; The Age of Caesar. Ed. Arthur Hugh Clough. Trans. John Dryden. Vol. IV. London: The Folio Society, 2010.
Pound, Ezra. "Homage to Sextus Propertius." The New Oxford Book of American Verse. Ed. Richard Ellmann. New York: Oxford University Press, 1976. 503.
Reynolds, L. D. and N. G. Wilson. Scribes and Scholars: A Guide to the Transmission of Greek and Latin Literature. Oxford: The Clarendon Press, 1991.
Romm, James, ed. The Landmark Arrian: The Campaigns of Alexander, Anabasis Alexandrou. Trans. Pamela Mensch. New York: Pantheon Books, 2010.
Sandys, John Edwin. A History of Classical Scholarship From the Sixth Century B.C. to the End of the Middle Ages. 2cond. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1906.
Strabo. The Geography of Strabo. Trans. Howard Leonard Jones. Vol. VIII. London: William Heinemann LTD., 1932.
—. The Geography of Strabo. Trans. Horace Leonard Jones. Vol. I. London: William Heinemann LTD., 1917.
The New Encyclopaedia Britannica: Macropaedia. 15th. Vol. 1. Chicago: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc., 1983.
Tooley, R. V. Maps and Map - Makers. New York: Dorset Press, 1987.
Vrettos, Theodore. Alexandria: City of the Western Mind. New York: The Free Press, 2001.
Wilford, John Noble. The Mapmakers: The Story of the Great Pioneers in Cartography from Antiquity to the Space Age. New York: Vintage Books, 1982.





[1] (Casson)33.
[2] (Parsons)58.
[3] (Knowles) 418. A poem by the British poet Ted Hughes, “Hear it Again” (1997) gives expression to the sense of loss felt by those who ponder the disappearance of the ancient library: “Fourteen centuries have learned,/From charred remains, that what took place/When Alexandria’s library burned/Brain-damaged the human race.”
[4] (Forster)7. “It is significant that our first glimpse of the coast should be through the eyes of a Greek sailor.”
[5] (Homer)135. Book 4: lines 395-401.
[6] (Wilford)18. “It was a magnificent city by the Mediterranean and at the delta of the Nile, a city of stone palaces, broad avenues, spacious parks, thriving shops, and a teeming harbor known to seaman by the stately white marble beacon on the island of Pharos.”
[7] (Durrell)108.  “They were drifting, Melissa and he, across the shallow blood-red waters of Mareotis, in each other’s arms, toward the rabble of mud-huts where once Rhakotis stood.”
[8] (The New Encyclopaedia Britannica: Macropaedia)497.
[9] (Romm)101.
[10] (Romm)101-102.
[11] Ibid.
[12] (Plutarch, Lives: Volume II; The Age of Empire-Builders)226.  “While he was pleasing himself with his design, on a sudden an infinite number of great birds of several kinds, rising like a black cloud out of the river and the lake, devoured every morsel of flour that had been used in setting out the lines, at which omen even Alexander himself was troubled, until the augers restored his confidence again by telling him it was a sign the city he was about to build would not only abound in all things within itself, but also be the nurse and feeder of many nations.  He commanded the workmen to proceed, while he went to visit the temple of Ammon.”
[13] (Romm)101-102.
[14] (Wilford)18.
[15] (Brazil)53.  “Octavian came to Alexandria in pursuit of Antony.  Antony died clumsily and conveniently at his own hand.  Precautions were taken to ensure that Cleopatra should remain alive to be the glittering trophy in the glorious triumph of Octavian back in Rome.  But Cleopatra would not be slave or vassal to anyone; she would be mistress of her own death either by the bite of an asp or the prick of a poisoned pin.”
[16] (Romm)423.
[17] (Baynham)328.
[18] (Baynham)327.  Note also, (Fraser)311: “Ptolemy I’s own important account of the campaigns of Alexander was certainly written in Alexandria, probably toward the end of his life.  The activity of the king seems to have stimulated contemporary interest in historical writing, for the two main historians who wrote in Alexandria, Hecataeus of Abdera and Manethon, both belonged to the reign of Soter, while historical writing subsequently played a very small part in the literary output of Alexandria.”
[19] (Sandys)105.
[20] (Baynham)329.
[21] (Durrell)39.  “As she speaks I am thinking of the founders of the city, the soldier-God in his glass coffin, the youthful body lapped in silver, riding down the river towards his tomb.”
[22] (Brazil)41.
[23]Ibid.
[24] Ibid.
[25] These Gospels are Matthew, Mark and Luke.  Mark is considered the oldest because he is used verbatim in the other two.  John is different, significantly, in his Gospel.
[26] (Ackroyd)37.
[27] (Ackroyd)39.
[28] (Bergreen)17. 
[29] (Howatson)193.
[30] (Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers)527.
[31] (Avery)864.
[32] (Howatson)563.
[33] (Howatson)435. “Aristotle taught in the groves and gymnasium of the Lyceum, where there were paths and walks, peripatoi, from which the school derived its name.”
[34] (Howatson)193. “He is thus partly responsible for their being organized in the Peripatetic fashion and spirit, which may account for the nature and trend of much of the intellectual life of Alexandria.”
[35] (Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers)527.
[36] (McEvedy)6.
[37] (Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers)527-531.  “For he enriched the city with revenues and buildings, though he was not of noble birth.” And: “For all his popularity with the Athenians he nevertheless suffered eclipse through all-devouring envy.”
[38] (McEvedy)6.
[39] (Manguel)188. “It may have been Demetrius of Phalerum – a scholar from Athens, the compiler of Aesop’s fables, a critic of Homer and a student of the celebrated Theophrastus (himself a student and friend of Aristotle)- who suggested to Alexander’s successor, Ptolemy I, the founding of the library that made Alexandria famous.”
[40] Ibid.
[41] Ibid.  See, also (Parsons)89. “…how can we doubt that this loyal son and benefactor of the Lyceum, this peripatetic philosopher, diplomat, and scholar, did not seize the opportunity to prepare for the king’s guests a permanent place of abode, where they would be surrounded by the tools of their profession in such prodigal profusion, as to tempt the most indolent and fire the enthusiasm of the energetic to intellectual achievements.  His position was secure, with access to the riches and the support of his royal patron whose noble aspirations he furthered.”
[42] (Fraser)308.  “The practice of inviting tutors for members of the royal family was inaugurated, as might be expected, by Soter and continued for several generations.  The princes were educated by the leading intellectual figures of the day, who were, during much of the third century at least, evidently also frequently Chief Librarians.”
[43] (Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers)531.
[44] Ibid.
[45] (Casson)31.
[46] (Howatson)553.
[47] (Nelles)533.
[48] (Howatson)553.
[49] (Manguel)189.
[50] (Battles)27.
[51] Ibid.
[52] (Casson)31.
[53] (Casson)28.
[54] (Parsons)4.  Parson notes, ruefully, that no mention of ancient titles is offered.
[55] (Manguel)189.  “For Aristotle, collecting books was part of the scholar’s labours, necessary ‘in the way of memoranda.’  The library of the city founded by his disciple was simply to be a vaster version of this: the memory of the world.”
[56] (Clark)17.
[57] (Canfora)139. Christian Callmer quote was originally published as “Antike Bibliotheken”; in Acta Instituti Romani Regni Suediae, 1944, p. 148.
[58] (Basbanes)15.  He goes on to note that: “A tidal wave that swamped the city in A.D. 365 also inflicted devastating damage, burying much of the waterfront beneath twenty feet of water.”
[59] (Howatson)33. 
[60] (Parsons)71.
[61] Ibid.
[62] (Manguel)189.
[63] (Reynolds and Wilson)7.
[64] (Sandys)111-112.
[65] Ibid.
[66] (Fraser)321.
[67] (Parsons)107.
[68] (Parsons)106.
[69] Ibid.
[70] (Fraser)321.
[71] Ibid.
[72] Ibid.
[73] (Howatson)541.
[74] Ibid.
[75] Ox.P.1241.
[76] (Fraser)321.
[77] (Parsons)116 gives 3 lists, all start with Zenodotus, and then continue: 1)Callimachus of Cyrene,  2)Eratothenes of Cyrene, 3)Apollonius of Rhodes, 4)Aristophanes of Byzantium, 5)Aristarchus of Samothrace OR 1)Apollonius of Alexandria, 2)Eratothenes, 3)Aristophanes of Byzantium, 4)Apollonius the “Classifier”, 5)Aristarchus of Samothrace OR 1)Callimachus, 2)Eratosthenes, 3)Aristophanes of Byzantium, 4)Apollonius the Eidograph, 5)Aristarchus.  Either way, we start with Zenodotus and end with Aristarchus.
[78] (Heller-Roazen)140. The Greek term translated to the title of chief librarian or head librarian in most accounts, actually translates literally as “guardian of books.”
[79] (Howatson)599.
[80] Ibid.  See also, (Reynolds and Wilson)10: “We come now to a brief discussion of the critical signs and the commentaries.  The first and most important sign was the obelos, a horizontal stroke placed in the margin just to the left of a verse.”
[81] (Casson)37.
[82] (Casson)43.
[83] Ibid.
[84] (Sandys)118. “The Alexandrian age is in the main an age of erudition and criticism.  Even its poets are often scholars.”
[85] (Knox, The Norton Book of Classical Literature)527. “The Roman poets of the first century B.C. all expressed their indebtedness to him.”
[86] Ibid. 553. An example: “He stooped to put flowers on his stepmother’s tomb, /Thinking she’d changed since meeting her doom. /He died when her gravestone fell on his head. /Stepmothers are dangerous even when dead.” Translated by Stanley Lombardo and Diane Rayor.
[87] Ezra Pound, the twentieth century poet, paid homage to both Callimachus and the earlier mentioned list-maker Philetas (Pound)503: “Shades of Callimachas, Coan ghosts of Philetas / It is in your grove I would walk, / I who come first from the clear font”.
[88] (Howatson)125.
[89] Ibid.
[90] Ibid.
[91] (Manguel)191-192.
[92] Ibid.
[93] (Reynolds and Wilson)7-8.
[94] (McEvedy)6-8.
[95] (Casson)41.
[96] (Manguel)192.
[97] (Heller-Roazen)143. “The ‘Tables’ appear to have been divided into sections, defined by genre, and subsections, composed of lists of works of individual authors.  Within each section , authors were classified alphabetically, and each entry included a short biographical sketch followed by enumeration of the author’s works, defined in turn by their opening words, their titles (where they had them: certain works of oratory and lyric poetry posed specific problems here), and an estimate of the number of lines of which each work consisted….”
[98] (Knox, The Oldest Dead White European Males and Other Reflections on the Classics)13-14.
[99] Ibid.
[100] Ibid.
[101] (Casson)36.
[102] (Casson)41.
[103] (Wilford)19. “Erastothenes must have been ideally suited to be a librarian.  He was a man of many parts, one who sampled and studied nearly all the learning of the day.”
[104] (Sandys)103. Here is a poem by Timon of Phlius (c. 320-c.250 BC): “In the thronging land of Egypt, /There are many that are feeding, /Many scribblers on papyrus /Ever ceaselessly contending, /In the bird-coop of the Muses.”
[105] (Howse and Sanderson)9.
[106] Ibid. “His method was simple.  Using existing field surveys of the fertile lands of the Nile Valley, He took the distance from Syene (modern Aswan) to Alexandria as 5,000 stadia (a stadium was about 200 yd).  Syene lay on the Tropic of Cancer and Erastothenes noticed that there was no shadow from a gnomon at the time of the summer solstice, whereas a similar gnomon at Alexandria threw a considerable shadow – whose length enabled him to calculate the angle subtended at the earth’s centre between Syene and Alexandria….”
[107] (Howatson)482.
[108] Ibid.
[109] (Tooley)6.
[110] (Sandys)111 – 112.
[111] Ibid.
[112] (Eliot)604.  “What is the city over the mountains /Cracks and reforms and bursts in the violet air /Falling towers /Jerusalem Athens Alexandria /Vienna London /Unreal”.
[113] (Gibbon)328-329.
[114] Ibid. 328.
[115] Ibid.
[116] Ibid.
[117] Ibid.
[118] Ibid. 329.
[119] Ibid. 329: “I shall not recapitulate the disasters of the Alexandrian library, the involuntary flame that was kindled by Caesar in his own defense, or the mischievous bigotry of the Christians, who studied to destroy the monuments of idolatry.”
[120] (Plutarch, Lives: Volume IV; The Age of Caesar)264.
[121] (Heller-Roazen)149.
[122] Ibid.  150-151: “One might be tempted to suggest that, had there not been a fire to consume the Library, one would have had to be invented: What fate, after all, could await the universal archive other than its destruction.  Real or imagined, the conflagration remains the supreme emblem of the Alexandrian archive itself, which sheltered the works of the past in exposing them to disaster, constituting and conserving its history in threatening itself with its own destruction.  For the very life of the Library, like that of the fire, was to nourish itself on what it consumed, to allow writing to live in outliving itself, bearing witness, in this way, to the catastrophe of the past in the present, the destruction of a tradition grown as “totally, eternally transient” as nature itself.” 

No comments:

Post a Comment